AniDex Forums

Discussion Forums => Manga => Topic started by: Dys on July 12, 2011, 09:31:56 am

Title: Manga: Anime Versions - The Manga Was Better
Post by: Dys on July 12, 2011, 09:31:56 am
A simple idea really.

A discussion about manga that received anime adaptions.

I commonly hear people saying that the anime wasn't as good as the manga.

The most recent and common example for me is Nichijou, which I've heard is quite inferior to its manga predecessor.

What are other manga that have received anime adaption, and was the anime really inferior?
Title: Re: Manga: Anime Versions - The Manga Was Better
Post by: AzureHakua on July 15, 2011, 01:38:46 am
I think that Bakuman's anime is inferior to the manga. The anime was really slowly paced, maybe like a chapter per episode which is ridiculously slow. Wait, I guess that means the manga wasn't better per say... The anime just sucked. xD
Title: Re: Manga: Anime Versions - The Manga Was Better
Post by: Tatsuya on July 23, 2011, 08:49:42 pm
I think the Air Gear anime is way to rushed, and ended without much of a continue, never to be seen a second season, in wich, the manga, is still going on, being awesome :<
Title: Re: Manga: Anime Versions - The Manga Was Better
Post by: XxanimefreakxX on July 25, 2011, 02:28:06 pm
i would say Yumekui merry, they did follow the manga in like the first 7 to 8 episodes, and then they strayed from it with a different story than the manga, but i still liked the anime despite that.^^
Title: Re: Manga: Anime Versions - The Manga Was Better
Post by: InfinityStream on July 25, 2011, 08:58:22 pm
Blue Exorcist. The episodes have been great so far but I'm afraid of what will happen to it when they get too close to the monthly adaptions.

We don't need another FMA indecent. Hell, they should have at least waited until chapter 50...
Title: Re: Manga: Anime Versions - The Manga Was Better
Post by: libertypo on July 27, 2011, 05:10:33 pm
Let me see...

Gokinjou Monogatari - The animation was just hideous. But Toei is not new to blunders like Gokinjou
Princess Princess - Was rushed on although there was material for a full season
Title: Re: Manga: Anime Versions - The Manga Was Better
Post by: Chadwicke on October 26, 2011, 05:26:45 am
Yo guys, I'd like some of your feedback about Needless Manga vs. Anime.

Through reading around I found out that the Anime strayed from the Manga to gain some kind of explosive ending. I don't know if that move was worth the ending they achieved, though.
Title: Re: Manga: Anime Versions - The Manga Was Better
Post by: InfinityStream on October 26, 2011, 11:05:51 pm
@Chadwicke

I personally would like to say that Needless Anime is pretty damn awesome. Especially the opening. I love the opening.